If these properties of human language make it such a unique communication system, quite different from the communication systems of other creatures, then it would seem extremely unlikely that other creatures would be able to understand it. Some humans, however, do not behave as if this is the case. There is, after all, a lot of spoken language directed by humans to animals, apparently under the impression that the animal follows what is being said. Riders can say Whoa to horses and they stop (or so it seems), we can say Heel to dogs and they will follow at heel (well, sometimes), and a variety of circus animals go Up, Down and Roll over in response to spoken commands. Should we treat these examples as evidence that non-humans can understand human language? Probably not. The standard explanation is that the animal produces a particular behavior in response to a particular sound-stimulus or noise, but does not actually “understand” what the words in the noise mean.

 If it seems difficult to conceive of animals understanding human language, then it appears to be even less likely that an animal would be capable of producing human language. After all, we do not generally observe animals of one species learning to produce the signals of another species. You could keep your horse in a field of cows for Animals and human language 15 years, but it still won’t say moo. And, in some homes, a new baby and a puppy may arrive at the same time. Baby and puppy grow up in the same environment, hearing mostly the same things, but about two years later, the baby is making lots of human speech sounds and the puppy is not. But perhaps a puppy is a poor example. Wouldn’t it be better to work with a closer relative such as a chimpanzee?

اخر الاخبار

اخبار العتبة العباسية المقدسة

بمشاركة الأمين العام للعتبة العبّاسية المقدّسة.. موكب عزاء السادة الخَدَم يحيي ليلة عاشوراء

صحفيّون يشيدون بالتسهيلات الإعلامية التي تقدّمها العتبة العباسية المقدّسة خلال زيارة عاشوراء

أهالي كربلاء ينظّمون مسيرة الشموع الحسينية إحياءً لليلة العاشر من شهر المحرّم

عبر مجلس عزاء.. العتبة العباسية المقدّسة تحيي ليلة اليوم العاشر من المحرّم

المزيد

الآخبار الصحية

لهذا السبب.. إغلاق 25 مركزًا لعلاج الإدمان في مصر ؟

خلافا للاعتقاد الشائع.. علماء يكشفون أسرار بذور البطيخ ؟!

هذا ما يحدث لجسمك عند تناولك الطماطم بانتظام !

تعرف على أطعمة تسرّع "تعافي الجسم" من حروق الشمس

المزيد

الآخبار التكنلوجية

الثلوج تغطي الصحراء الأكثر جفافا في العالم!

بتلسكوب "ألما".. التقاط صورا غير مسبوقة لبدايات الكون !

هل هاتفك مراقب؟.. 5 علامات خطيرة تكشف التجسس عليك

دبي تطلق أول رحلة تجريبية للتاكسي الجوي

المزيد

مواضيع ذات صلة

A case study of the semantics of clear - The framework – a version of Gunlogsons model of context update

Interpreting the experiencer of a discourse adjective

Discourse adjectives are not factive

Preliminary observations about discourse adjectives

Discourse adjectives Introduction

Evaluatives in interrogatives

Prosody, scope, and pragmatic status

The fragment of grammar

On embedded evaluatives

Evaluative adverbs and dialogue - Modeling ancillary commitments

Evaluative adverbs and dialogue - Evaluatives as ancillary commitments

Evaluative adverbs and adjectives