The contested impact of cognitive linguistic research on the psycholinguistics of metaphor understanding
Embodied metaphor understanding: recent experimental evidence
Embodied simulations in understanding metaphorical narratives
Consider the following two brief narratives about the development of two different romantic relationships.
Story A
Imagine that you are a single person. A friend sets you up on a blind date. You really like this person and start dating a lot. Your relationship was moving along in a good direction. But then it got even better. The relationship felt like it was the best you ever had. This continues to this day. No matter what happens, the two of you are quite happy together.
Story B
Imagine that you are a single person. A friend sets you up on a blind date. You really like this person and start dating a lot. Your relationship was moving along in a good direction. But then you encountered some difficulties. The relationship did not feel the same as before. This lasted for some time. No matter how hard you two tried, the two of you were not getting along.
Story A and B differ in that A describes a successful relationship, while B describes a relationship that appears to be in trouble. Both stories are similar, however, in conceiving of the relationships as entities that can move along some sort of path (RELATIONSHIPS ARE JOURNEYS), as indicated in the fourth line “Your relationship was moving along in the good direction.” Although no other part of the two stories explicitly refers to journeys, the two stories provide different impressions of the “relationship journey.” Thus, Story A suggests a smooth, uninterrupted journey that is still progressing, while Story B implies a more difficult, perhaps interrupted, journey that may no longer be progressing.
When college students read the two stories above, they specifically judged the successful metaphorical relationships to be progressing further, moving along in a straighter line and the story participants to be heading more in the same direction than was the case for the unsuccessful metaphorical story (Gibbs 2006b). There is nothing in the metaphorical stories that directly assert anything about the distance, speed, extent, and direction of the relationship “journeys” traveled. All of these inferences were drawn on the basis of people’s metaphorical understandings of the stories as referring to RELATIONSHIPS ARE JOURNEYS (with RELATIONSHIP ARE VEHICLES TRAVELING ALONG A PATH as a possible more specific instantiation), as suggested by the “Your relationship was moving along in a good direction” statement.
One new set of studies used a new methodology to examine whether people’s interpretations of simple narratives, like the above stories, partly rely on their embodied understandings of the metaphors involved (Gibbs 2006b). The hypothesis examined was that people infer the detailed meanings of simple narratives involving conceptual metaphors by imagining their participating in the metaphorical actions explicitly mentioned in these stories. For example, when hearing “moving along in a good direction,” listeners imagine engaging in a body action, such as traveling along some path, which facilitates their metaphoric understanding of the abstract, and physically impossible, idea that romantic relationships can move along a path toward some goal. If people imaginatively simulate themselves in the journey, then listening to these different renditions of the RELATIONSHIPS ARE JOURNEYS conceptual metaphor should have different real world embodied effects. To assess this idea, people listened to one of the two above stories, were blindfolded, and then walked along a path toward an object while they thought about the story. People should walk differently when hearing successful and unsuccessful metaphor stories, while these effects should be greatly attenuated after hearing nonmetaphorical narratives that did not suggest a conceptualization of the relationship as a kind of physical journey.
This hypothesis was tested in a novel manner by having participants physically walk toward an object, 40 feet away, after hearing either a successful or unsuccessful story in either the metaphorical or nonmetaphorical condition. Another experimental condition asked participants to simply imagine walking to the object after hearing one of the stories. Analysis of the walking times generally showed that people walked significantly longer for the successful metaphorical stories (15.7 seconds) than for the unsuccessful metaphorical stories (12.8 seconds), but that this difference was not reliable in the nonmetaphorical condition (14.8 and 14.6 seconds). Analysis of the length of walking (in vertical relationship to the target) again showed that people walked further for the successful stories (2 feet 4 inches beyond the object) than for the unsuccessful ones (2 feet 3 inches below the object).
Analysis of the walking times generally showed that people walked significantly longer for the successful metaphorical stories (15.7 seconds) than for the unsuccessful metaphorical stories (12.8 seconds), but that this difference was not reliable in the nonmetaphorical condition (14.8 and 14.6 seconds). Analysis of the length of walking (in vertical relationship to the target) again showed that people walked further for the successful stories (2 feet 4 inches beyond the object) than for the unsuccessful ones (2 feet 3 inches below the object).
Another experimental condition asked participants to simply imagine walking to the object after hearing one of the stories. For the imagined condition, participants were blindfolded, heard a story, but were then instructed to only imagine walking out to the yellow ball as they thought about the story, and to press a stopwatch as soon as they imagined arriving at the ball. The results of the imagine condition showed that people imagined walking longer for the successful metaphor stories (11.4 seconds) than for the unsuccessful metaphoric narratives (9.5 seconds). Unlike the data for the walking condition, where no difference was obtained, people imagined walking longer in the unsuccessful condition (12.5 seconds) than in the successful one (9.5 seconds). The reason for this latter finding is not clear.
These studies suggest that people’s interpretation of the stories partly involved creating an embodied simulation, or a reenactment, of the relationship journey alluded to in the different metaphorical narratives. Even though relationships are not physical entities that literally travel along physical paths, people nonetheless conceive of relationships in metaphorical ways, especially when prompted to do so by statements like “Your relationship was moving along in a good direction.” This metaphorical conceptualization is not purely abstract, but embodied in the sense that participants imagine themselves moving in the different relationship journeys, perhaps together in a vehicle, which subsequently affected their walking, and imagining of walking, as they thought about the stories.